Showing posts with label TV. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TV. Show all posts

Monday, 22 December 2008

Do I want to be Harry Redknapp?

OK, so this post is a bit rant inspired but, I was driving down the M4 into London yesterday afternoon and noticed a Nintendo poster hosting a picture of Harry Redknapp and the line “Play Mario Kart like The Redknapps”.

For some reason it really pissed me off and took a bit of the shine off my own love of Mario Kart (virtually unbeatable as Luigi I might add!). The ad was rough and ready, unimaginative and very, well, not-Nintendo. But there was something else that bugged me that I couldn’t put my finger on. It’s not that I disapprove of celebrities advertising products, I actually quite like the matching TV ads showing the Redknapps, Patrick Stewart, Girls Aloud and co having fun with various Nintendo stuff. So what was it? What was different? (Other than the fact one’s a poster and one’s on tele.)

This got me thinking about Carl Hovland. Whilst working as part of the US World War II propaganda machine Hovland examined various ways to present a persuasive message. He concluded that the most effective approach to persuasion is to present an audience with a logical argument showing how changing their attitudes or behaviour will benefit them. For example:

Or, in the case of the Wii TV ads, we’re told that we should buy Mario Kart as playing it with all the family means we’ll have a great time, as shown by the Redknapps doing exactly that. Sounds pretty logical. What about the posters? Here we’re told that if we buy Mario Kart we can be like the Redknapps.

Now this is a different message and where I think they’ve gone off piste. I don’t actually want to be Harry Redknapp (despite having Louise Redknapp as a daughter in law); I just want to have fun with my family like he does on the tele.

Hovland developed his theories further and, in 1953, presented the “Yale Communication Study”, the basic premise of which remains well known and well used today. In trying to persuade people there are four main variables: Who says what to whom by what means.

In the case of the Mario Kart example not only has the ‘what’ (message) and the ‘means’ (TV to poster) changed, but also the ‘who’. For the TV ads it was the Redknapps telling me that Mario Kart was great, on the posters it’s Nintendo.

It is generally agreed that, amidst a range of factors, the degree of involvement of the ‘who’ with the ‘what’ (message) affects the audience’s interpretation and evaluation of it (Social Judgement Theory). For instance, we’re more likely to believe our neighbour who owns the same car as the one we’re considering buying than the retailer who’s trying to flog it to us. Similarly, we’re more likely to listen to our pals the Redknapps who, after all, look just like our very own happy family than we are Nintendo, the manufacturer of the game.

Of course, I’m not suggesting that companies shouldn’t advertise directly (that would just be silly) more that the posters have missed the crux of the Nintendo campaign. It’s meant to be about the Redknapps showing how good the game is, not Nintendo trying to turn us into minor celebrities.

Maybe it’s just me. Maybe I just don’t want to be told so overtly that I want to be like the Redknapps because secretly I do? Or maybe I’m worried little Louise Redknapp would actually whoop my Luigi alter ego? Or maybe the posters are just crap?

I think I’m with the latter. (Luigi would definitely win.)

Tuesday, 24 June 2008

Public Service Narrrowcasting

Ofcom predicts that by 2012 100% of the UK will have digital multi-channel TV. Despite the current strength of commercial broadcasters such as Sky and Virgin this should actually be great news for Public Service Broadcasters (PSB). Niche channels for niche programmes designed for niche audiences, a real way to satisfy all tastes of our culturally and demographically varied population. Gone are the days of us young city folk liking or lumping the latest topical farming issue on the Archers. We’ll all head to the American version of the Apprentice on our channel instead.

To be fair, multi-channel TV has been around for a while now and there have been some real success stories, especially amongst the sports, movies and generic entertainment channels. But there have also been some losers, most notably the likes of science, nature, classical music and history (the clever stuff you might say). Sadly a nature programme on a nature channel will be lucky to get 1% of the audience it could have received on wide-ranging BBC2.

One could argue that this is natural selection, democracy working at its best, people voting with their index fingers. However, niche channelling is rather anti-PSB. According to Ofcom Public Service Broadcasting has a duty to:

  • increase our understanding of the world
  • stimulate our knowledge and learning
  • reflect our UK cultural identity
  • to ensure diversity and alternative viewpoints are represented

Its aim, and indeed its success, is based not just on audience size but also on its schedule range.

David Attenborough, writing for The Times, is in firm support pointing out that the role of PSB is to cater for the whole population, not segregate it – Broad-casting, not Narrow-casting. He supports this argument by suggesting that many people hold ‘allegiances’ with specific PSBs: “the notion that great numbers of people, tired after a hard day's work, come home and flip through 50-odd programme channels to decide what to view is, in fact, largely illusory.”

I’m with Attenborough on this one. As Cowper (the guy who did the “variety is the spice of life quote”) says “The earth was made so various, that the mind of desultory man, studious of change and pleased with novelty, might be divulged”. It is down to our PSBs to do this ‘divulging’ (after all, nearly all of us pay for them).

However, from an advertising perspective niche channels (whether fully commercial or part public), should be the way forward. Greater ability to target audiences, more tailored creative, better media positioning, less wastage, and so on. Yet this is often not the case, if only due to incompetent media buying. As a youngish, laddish, fan of witty banter I’m partial to a bit of Top Gear and Never Mind the Buzzcocks on ‘Dave – The Home of Witty Banter’. I’m less partial to the breast milk and tampon adverts in the breaks though.

Ultimately a wider variety of content can only be good for the consumer but the digital world is asking questions of Public Service Broadcasting and their offerings (note BBC tackling it head on with its iPlayer). As Petrarch said, “Sameness is the mother of disgust, variety the cure”. It will be interesting to see what the cure is in 2012.

Monday, 31 March 2008

Chocolate guru or marketing extraordinaire?

OK, I’ll own up straight away to watching the latest Charlie and the Chocolate Factory film this Saturday (the one with Johnny Depp in). As expected, aside from some disappointing Oompa Loompas (where's their green hair gone?), it wasn’t that bad. What I didn’t expect was to find that chocolate fanatic Willy Wonka is actually a bit of a marketing guru-cum-futurologist.

I won’t regurgitate the full plot but in a later scene Charlie visits the ‘TV room’ with Wonka and the only other child left on the factory tour, Mike Teavee. They are introduced to Wonka's new machine, the Television Chocolate Camera. This gizmo can take a giant bar of Wonka’s Chocolate and shrink it into a little sample before sending it into millions of televisions across the world. People watching their TVs can then reach in, take the sample and take a bite of the chocolate.

Although Mike Teavee vents his frustration at Wonka for not realising that he’s accidently invented a teleporter, Wonka’s real achievement is creating the ultimate in product placement (at least for the purpose of this blog!).

Imagine sampling the last bit of milk in a Cravendale ad or helping yourself to a Cadbury’s Miniature Hero before Corrie started. Or even watching Corrie and reaching in for a spoon of “Betty’s Hot Pot” – now available in all good pub chains!

Now this is all very fanciful but Rory Sutherland recently made an interesting point about ‘the medium being the product’. He notes that allowing people to respond to a DM pack by telephone or post increased response rates. This, logically, seemed strange as the key question should simply be “Do you want this product or not?” Similarly, low-cost airlines increased their customer base by using online booking - a simple effort to cut costs actually overcame the irritation of being stuck on the phone for half an hour. A simple opt-in box for Gift Aid when donating online has resulted in the generation of more money for charity. There are numerous examples.

Basically, the easier it is for consumers to reply/respond/purchase/taste/etc, the easier it is to sell the product. And Willy Wonka cracked this (well, Roald Dahl really).

TV’s tried telephone call to actions, and online, and even had a dabble with red buttons. But what it really needs is a Television Chocolate Camera. Until then it’s playing catch up with other, newer, media. Just look at those SIM only Orange banners. See the banner on a website, fill in your details without having to leave your site, 3 days later you’ve got yourself a SIM card in your postbox. Awesome.

Until then, anyone for a Smell-o-vision renassiance?